CBS News has announced that JD Vance and Tim Walz will not be fact-checked during the upcoming vice presidential debate. This decision has sparked two reactions from me. Firstly, I see this as an act of cowardice and a failure of journalism. Secondly, I find it hard to believe that this will actually be the case.
In previous discussions, I have emphasized the importance of moderators in debates, which I refer to as “The Moderator Imperative.” Moderators should do more than just ask questions and keep time. They should guide the debate, ensure that answers stay on track, and challenge any misleading information presented by the candidates.
It is crucial for moderators to be well-prepared and knowledgeable about the topics being discussed. They should be able to distinguish between facts and fiction and ensure that the audience receives accurate information.
The rise of Donald Trump and his tendency to spread falsehoods at an unprecedented rate has added a new layer of complexity to the role of moderators. While the fundamental job remains the same, the unique challenges presented by Trump’s behavior require moderators to adapt and be vigilant in fact-checking.
Criticism of moderators who fact-check Trump more than other candidates should be viewed in the context of the significant difference between typical political evasion and outright lies. Moderators must be able to discern between the two and hold candidates accountable for spreading misinformation.
As the upcoming vice presidential debate approaches, it is essential for moderators Norah O’Donnell and Margaret Brennan to uphold the standards of journalism and ensure that Vance and Walz are held accountable for their statements. The integrity of the debate and the credibility of the candidates are at stake.
In conclusion, journalists must not be swayed by criticism or external pressure. It is our responsibility to uphold the truth and provide a platform for meaningful discourse. Failure to do so would compromise the integrity of our profession and have lasting consequences. Let us rise to the occasion and fulfill our duty to the public.
